✕

Exterior Installation Services For Your Home

Everything You Need to Upgrade Your Home’s Exterior — All in One Place, with Reliable Repair Solutions to Keep Your Home Protected Across MA & RI.

Bruin Corporation of Attleboro Bigstock Professional Window Installer X

Windows

Energy-efficient window installation that improves comfort, natural light, and home performance plus expert repairs for drafts, leaks, and damaged frames.

Bruin Corporation of Attleboro Effdffdda Installing Front Door

Doors

Secure and stylish door installation for entry and patio spaces including reliable repair solutions for wear, damage, and insulation issues.

Bruin Corporation of Attleboro Odyssey Contracting Vinyl Siding Replacement

Siding

Durable siding installation designed to boost curb appeal and protection — with repair services for cracks, weather damage, and aging materials.

Bruin Corporation of Attleboro A Group Of Men Working On A Roof In Logan Utah

Roofing

High-quality roofing installation built for long-term protection — along with dependable repair services for leaks, missing shingles, and storm damage.

Bruin Corporation of Attleboro Blown In Attic Insulation Toronto

Insulation

Advanced insulation solutions that improve energy efficiency and indoor comfort, with repair and upgrades for outdated or ineffective insulation.

Bruin Corporation of Attleboro Upvc Door Repair Options And Costs

Repairs

Comprehensive repair services for roofing, siding, windows, and doors, keeping your home protected, efficient, and performing at its best.

Homeowners: 10×10 Test Squares That Prove Hail Damage on Your Roof

If your roof shows clustered circular bruises, exposed black mat, or fresh shiny dents in vents and gutters, that pattern usually means real hail impact, not just cosmetic wear. Stay off the roof. Photograph the ground-level damage first, then schedule a professional inspection if you see those signs repeated across a slope or matched by stains inside the attic.


TL;DR:

  • Hail causes impact marks that usually appear as random bruises, granule loss, or shiny dents in vents and gutters, often concentrated on one or two slopes.
  • Professional inspections involve marking test squares, counting qualifying hits, and conducting press tests to detect structural damage not visible to the naked eye.
  • Ground-level evidence such as dents in gutters and fresh granules can help assess damage without climbing on the roof, but a full evaluation requires a trained inspector.
  • Insurers often consider around eight qualifying impacts per 100 square feet as a threshold for roof replacement, with results typically compared slope by slope.
  • Documenting storm timing, taking photos, keeping fragments, and obtaining a detailed report before signing repair contracts reduces disputes and speeds claim processing.

Table of Contents

What Hail Damage Looks Like By Roof Material

Hail doesn’t treat every roofing material the same way, and knowing what’s normal for yours saves you from either panicking over nothing or missing real damage.

On asphalt and composition shingles, look for random circular bruises, patches where the granules have washed away, and spots where the black asphalt mat underneath is exposed and looks shiny. Travelers Insurance notes that a genuinely hail-hit shingle often feels soft when you press on it, because the impact fractures the mat underneath even when the surface looks fine.

Metal, tile, and other materials show their own tells:

  • Soft metals (roof vents, gutters, flashing) dent easily and show fresh, shiny impact marks that are hard to fake or misattribute.
  • Tile cracks in a distinctive starburst pattern radiating from the impact point.
  • Standing-seam or coated metal panels show small dents and sometimes chipped or missing paint at the strike point.
  • Cedar shakes split along the grain rather than denting.
  • Flat or low-slope membranes can show punctures or bruising that’s easy to miss without walking the surface.

The trickier part is telling hail apart from normal aging. Blistering and thermal cracking tend to follow the roof’s natural stress lines and show up gradually across the whole surface. Hail damage shows up suddenly, in random, scattered impact points, often worse on one or two slopes that faced the storm directly.

How Does a Professional Hail Inspection Actually Work?

A trained inspector isn’t just eyeballing your shingles. They’re running a semi-standardized forensic process, and understanding it helps you know what a solid report should include.

  1. Mark test squares. Inspectors chalk off 10 by 10 foot sections, known as test squares, on each slope rather than sampling the whole roof at once. Multiple squares per slope give a more honest read than one lucky (or unlucky) patch.
  2. Count qualifying hits. Each square gets a hit count of impacts that meet a real damage threshold, not just surface scuffs.
  3. Run the press test. Pressing on suspect shingles reveals soft spots that signal a fractured mat underneath, something a photo alone can’t always show.
  4. Check soft metals. Vents, pipe boots, and flashing get inspected for dents, since they corroborate hail impact without the ambiguity granule loss sometimes creates.
  5. Look inside. Attic and interior checks catch water staining or light coming through that confirms functional, not just cosmetic, damage.

A common insurer benchmark is roughly 8 qualifying hits per 100 square feet before a slope is considered for replacement, though the exact threshold varies by carrier and policy. Adjusters generally compare results slope by slope rather than averaging across the whole roof, since one side of the house often takes the brunt of a storm. A written, dated report with per-slope photos is what actually moves a claim forward when there’s any disagreement about cause.

What Should You Check From The Ground After A Storm?

You don’t need to get on a ladder to gather useful evidence, and honestly, you shouldn’t.

  • Grab binoculars and photograph what you can see from the ground on every side of the house.
  • Check gutters and downspouts for fresh granules pooled at the bottom and dents along the edges.
  • Look at vents, flashing, AC unit fins, window screens, and painted trim for splatter marks or dings.
  • Write down the storm’s date and time, and cross-check it against NOAA’s Storm Prediction Center hail data for your area.
  • Keep timestamped photos and video, and save any fragments of shingle or siding that fell during the storm.

Pro Tip: Don’t sign a repair contract with anyone until you have your own written documentation in hand. A rushed signature is the single most common regret homeowners report after a bad storm-chaser experience.

How Do You Document Hail Damage For An Insurance Claim?

Good documentation is often the difference between a smooth claim and a drawn-out fight, since insurers weigh evidence heavily when deciding whether damage ties to a specific storm event versus pre-existing wear.

  1. Shoot wide, then close. Take full elevation photos of each side of the roof, then close-ups of individual impact points, soft-metal dents, and gutter damage. Include a landmark or fixed object in a few shots for context.
  2. Protect the originals. Keep unedited photo files with their metadata intact, and note the storm date directly in your records rather than relying on memory.
  3. Call your insurer early. Ask about your claim filing window and deductible before damage gets worse from exposure.
  4. Bring your evidence to the adjuster. Request a written report with per-slope photos and notes, since a defensible report links specific observations to the storm timing rather than making a vague general call.
  5. Consider a second opinion. If your claim gets denied or the repair estimate runs high, a paid independent inspection or structural engineer review adds a neutral voice to the dispute. You can also review how homeowners insurance handles roof leak claims before that conversation.

When Should You Call a Professional Roofer?

Certain signs mean it’s time to stop guessing and get someone qualified on the roof.

  • Impacts clustered on one or two slopes rather than scattered randomly.
  • Granule loss exposing the black mat across multiple shingles.
  • Soft spots that show up during a press test.
  • Water stains or light spots appearing in the attic after a storm.
  • Fresh dents in soft metal across several parts of the exterior, which you can cross-reference with hail damage patterns on siding.

When you’re vetting who to call, ask directly about their test-square protocol, whether they deliver written reports with per-slope photos, and whether they’re licensed and insured. Get a written estimate before committing to anything. Watch for red flags: unsolicited door-to-door crews right after a storm, pressure to sign the same day, or a report with no photos to back it up. Many contractors, including established roofing services, offer free initial checks, while a neutral paid inspection typically runs $150 to $400 and is worth it if you expect the claim to be contested.

Why Homeowners Overestimate What They Can Judge Alone

Most people assume hail damage will look dramatic, like a roof that’s visibly falling apart. It usually doesn’t. The damage that actually costs you money, mat fracture under a shingle, a hairline crack in a vent boot, is often invisible from the driveway and sometimes invisible from the roof surface itself until someone presses on it. That’s the gap between what homeowners can reasonably assess and what an inspection is built to catch.

The conventional advice to “just look for dents” undersells how much the press test and soft-metal check matter. A shingle can look fine and still be structurally compromised, which is exactly why insurers lean on measured test squares instead of a quick walkthrough. If there’s one thing worth pushing back on, it’s the idea that a phone-camera survey from the ground is a substitute for someone qualified checking multiple slopes with a real protocol. It isn’t, and treating it as one is how homeowners end up under-claiming real damage or, less often, chasing damage that turns out to be ordinary aging.

— Jess

Get a Written Hail Damage Report Before You Sign Anything

Bruin Corp of Attleboro gives you something a lot of post-storm door knockers won’t: a written, per-slope inspection report with dated photos before anyone asks you to sign a repair order. With over 40 years in business and more than 11,000 completed projects across Massachusetts and Rhode Island, our teams document soft-metal dents, granule loss, and press-test results the same way an adjuster expects to see them.

Bruin Corp of Attleboro

If the inspection points to repair rather than full replacement, we’ll walk you through both options honestly, and if the damage is significant, our storm damage repair services and roof replacement crews can move fast. Larger projects can be spread out with financing options built around real project budgets. Reach out through our contact page to schedule an inspection and get your documentation started before you talk to your adjuster.

Where to Verify Hail Size and Inspection Standards

Where to Verify Hail Size and Inspection Standards — overview diagram

For hailstone size and storm severity, NOAA’s Storm Prediction Center hail-size table is the standard reference. For inspection methodology, InterNACHI’s forensic hail damage guidance outlines how inspectors examine impact patterns across a roof. For disputed high-value claims, a structural engineer’s review adds an independent, technical opinion.

Sources

FAQ

How Do I Know If My Roof Has Hail Damage?

Look for random circular bruises on shingles, spots where granules are missing and the black mat shows through, and fresh dents in vents, gutters, or flashing. If those signs cluster on one slope or show up alongside attic staining, it’s worth a professional inspection.

What Size Hail Causes Roof Damage?

Damage risk rises noticeably once hailstones reach roughly one inch in diameter, though wind speed and shingle age both affect the outcome. The SPC hail-size table is the standard reference for matching hailstone size to likely severity.

How Much Does a Hail Damage Roof Inspection Cost?

Many roofing contractors offer free initial hail inspections, while a neutral, paid independent inspection typically costs $150 to $400 and is worth considering if you expect your claim to be disputed.

Can I Inspect My Roof for Hail Damage Myself?

You can safely check ground-level evidence like gutters, vents, and siding, but a full assessment requires walking the roof, running a press test, and counting hits per test square, which is best left to a trained professional.

Does Hail Damage Always Show Up Right Away?

Most functional damage, like mat fracture or a cracked vent boot, is visible shortly after the storm if you know where to look, though some leaks and interior staining can take weeks to appear after repeated rain.