Ice and water shield is a self-adhering waterproof membrane that goes directly on the roof deck, under the shingles, in the places where water is most likely to get in: eaves, valleys, and around penetrations. It seals around roofing nails and stops water that ice dams or wind-driven rain push up under the shingles. It is not a replacement for shingles, and it is not the right choice for every square foot of every roof. Below is how it works, where it belongs, how it compares with felt, what it costs, and what to ask your roofer.
TL;DR
- Ice and water shield is a rubberized-asphalt (polymer-modified bitumen) membrane with a sticky back. It bonds to the deck and seals around nails, which felt cannot do.
- At minimum it belongs along the eaves, in valleys, and under flashing at chimneys, skylights, and vent pipes. Code in snow country sets how far up the roof it runs.
- Mainstream rolls run roughly $0.40 to $1.12 per square foot in materials. Installed cost depends on roof shape, access, and local labor.
- Covering the whole deck is rarely necessary and can trap moisture if the attic is not ventilated well.
- It does not stop ice dams from forming. Air sealing, insulation, and ventilation do that.
Table of Contents
- What ice and water shield is
- Why roofs in our area need it
- Roofing underlayment types, and how ice and water shield compares
- Where to install ice and water shield
- Should you cover the entire roof?
- What building code requires
- How it is installed
- What ice and water shield costs
- Our perspective: protect the eaves, then fix the attic
- Repair or replace: when the membrane question comes up
- Having your roof done with Bruin
- FAQ
- Sources
What ice and water shield is
The name started as a brand name, and people now use it for the whole product category. Manufacturers also sell it as ice and water protector, ice barrier, or peel-and-stick underlayment. The product is a waterproof underlayment made with polymer-modified bitumen. A release film on the back peels off, and the adhesive bonds the sheet to the plywood or OSB deck.
Two features make it different from other underlayments:
- It bonds to the deck. When the side and end laps are done properly, they form a watertight seal instead of a loose overlap.
- It self-seals around fasteners. Every shingle nail is a tiny hole in a roof. The membrane is designed to close around those nail penetrations, so water that gets past the shingles has a much harder time reaching the wood.
That second point matters most in a New England winter. When a roof leaks under an ice dam, the water rarely comes in through a missing shingle. It comes in sideways and upward, through the overlaps and the nail holes.
Why roofs in our area need it
Ice dams form when heat escaping from the house melts snow on the roof. The meltwater runs down to the cold eave, where it refreezes. The U.S. Department of Energy’s Building America program explains that backed-up water can get beneath shingles and leak into the attic. Shingles shed water that runs downhill. They are not built to hold back a pool of water that is standing against them.
The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) recommends an ice-dam protection layer along the eaves to protect against leakage if dams do form. Wind-driven rain is the other threat. Heavy coastal storms can push water up and under shingle tabs, and the same membrane handles that too.
One thing people get wrong: the membrane is a leak barrier, not an ice preventer. Fine Homebuilding’s Mike Guertin makes the point that an “ice barrier” does not stop ice from forming. It limits the damage when ice forms anyway. To cut down on the dams themselves, you have to deal with heat loss. Building America lists air sealing, attic insulation, and ventilation as the way to reduce the heat transfer behind ice dams. Our guide on air sealing the ceiling before adding insulation and ventilation walks through the order of work, and this piece on ice dams and attic insulation covers what actually keeps them from forming.
Roofing underlayment types, and how ice and water shield compares
Underlayment is the layer between the roof deck and the shingles. The three basic types, as Pro Builder describes them, are felt, synthetic, and self-adhered.
| Felt (asphalt-saturated) | Synthetic | Self-adhered (ice and water shield) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Paper or fiberglass mat saturated with asphalt | Polypropylene or polyester sheet, usually nailed or stapled | Asphalt and rubber polymers with a sticky back |
| Attachment | Nailed or stapled | Nailed or stapled | Peel-and-stick |
| Seals around nails | No | No | Yes |
| Water resistance | Moderate; can tear or wrinkle when wet | Good | Highest; a sealed, watertight layer |
| Relative cost | Usually lowest | Higher than felt | Highest per square foot |
| Typical use | Field of the roof | Field of the roof | Eaves, valleys, penetrations, low slopes |
Ice and water shield vs felt
Felt is made by saturating paper or fiberglass mat with asphalt. ARMA notes that ASTM D226 covers it in two grades: Type I, commonly called No. 15 felt, and the heavier Type II, commonly called No. 30. Felt is inexpensive and has a long track record under shingles. Pro Builder reports that felt is generally less durable when exposed, and that it can tear or wrinkle when wet.
The real difference is function. Felt is a secondary water-shedding layer. Ice and water shield is a sealed waterproofing layer. You would not use it everywhere because of cost, and you would not use felt at the eaves of a New England house because it cannot handle standing water.
Ice and water shield vs underlayment
This comparison is a little off, because ice and water shield is an underlayment. The practical question is whether you want it as the only underlayment or only in the vulnerable zones. Most roofs in our area get a hybrid: self-adhered membrane at eaves, valleys, and penetrations, and felt or synthetic underlayment over the rest. The Department of Energy’s Building Science Education page describes the same approach, with peel-and-stick membranes at vulnerable transitions, metal flashing at intersections, and conventional underlayment elsewhere.
Best underlayment for asphalt shingles
There is no single best product, because each layer does a different job. For asphalt shingles on a typical pitched roof, a sound setup is:
- Self-adhered membrane along the eaves, in valleys, and around penetrations.
- Synthetic or felt underlayment across the rest of the deck.
- Metal drip edge and flashing detailed correctly over and under those layers.
Check your shingle manufacturer’s installation instructions as well. Some require specific underlayments to keep the shingle warranty valid, and your roofer should be able to show you where.
Where to install ice and water shield
IKO lists eaves, rake edges, overhangs, and valleys as the common locations. It also recommends protection beneath flashing at chimneys and vent stacks, around penetrations such as dormers and skylights, and on low-slope roofs. In practice, that means:
- Eaves. The first line of defense against ice dams. Run it from the roof edge up past the exterior wall line (see the code section below).
- Valleys. Water from two roof planes funnels into valleys, so they see the most flow. The Building America valley guidance says to center the membrane and install it from the lowest point upward with 6-inch shingle-style overlaps, keep it flat with no gaps or creases, and roll it firmly.
- Penetrations. Vent pipes, plumbing stacks, and skylights need pieces that seal tightly around the pipe and overlap the adjacent underlayment. Chimneys are the classic trouble spot. If you have a leak near one, read how to diagnose a chimney roof leak before paying twice, and for skylights see how to fix a leaking skylight.
- Where roof planes meet walls. The Department of Energy’s guidance also places membrane where roof planes abut walls, under step and wall flashing.
- Low-slope sections. IKO points to roof areas of roughly 2:12 to 4:12 as higher risk, because snow can drift there and ice dams can extend farther up the slope. Shingles are only designed to shed water at a certain pitch. On shallow sections, a sealed membrane is what keeps water out.
For underlayment on low-slope roofs, many manufacturers allow shingles on shallow pitches only with a full self-adhered layer beneath. Confirm the minimum slope in your shingle maker’s instructions, since it varies by product.
Should you cover the entire roof?
It is a common question, and the honest answer is: sometimes, and rarely by default.
The case for it is real. Full-deck coverage can prevent leaks if high winds blow shingles off, since the deck stays sealed underneath. On a complicated roof with many valleys, dormers, and penetrations, it can also simplify the detailing.
The case against is moisture. IKO says that covering the full deck is not advisable in most circumstances, partly because the membrane can act as a vapor barrier, and other underlayments typically cost less. ARMA cautions that full-deck self-adhering membranes act as vapor retarders, so adequate roof or attic ventilation becomes increasingly important to reduce condensation risk.
In plain terms: if warm, humid air from the house reaches the underside of a sealed deck, moisture has nowhere to go. That is why we look at the attic before recommending full coverage. If the attic is well air-sealed, insulated, and vented, full-deck coverage on a tricky roof can make sense. If not, fix the attic first. Whatever you choose, follow your local code.
What building code requires
The model code most states build from is the International Residential Code. Section R905.1.2 says that where there has been a history of ice forming along the eaves and backing up water, an ice barrier must be installed under asphalt shingles. The barrier is either at least two layers of underlayment cemented together or a self-adhering polymer-modified bitumen sheet. It must extend from the lowest edge of the roof to a point at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line. On roofs with a slope of 8:12 or steeper, it must also run at least 36 inches up the slope from the eave edge.
Two details trip people up:
- The 24 inches is measured inside the wall line, not from the roof edge. With a deep overhang, a single 36-inch roll may not reach far enough. Many roofers run a second course or use the wider coverage to get there.
- Local adoption matters. ARMA states that U.S. model codes require an ice barrier where ice has formed along eaves, and its recommended minimum is 24 inches inside the interior wall line. Building America recommends self-sealing membrane in IECC Climate Zones 5 and higher, and notes that local code details can exceed the common 24-inch minimum.
Ice and water shield in Massachusetts and Rhode Island
Both states sit in cold-climate territory where ice dams are a normal winter event, and both base their residential codes on the IRC with state amendments. Because each state and sometimes each town applies its own edition and amendments, the exact distance is a question for your local building department or your roofer’s permit paperwork. A licensed contractor pulling a permit for a re-roof in Attleboro, Mansfield, or Foxboro will already have the current requirement in hand. Ask for it in writing on your proposal.
How it is installed
Installation order matters, and it is where a roof either works or does not. Per IKO’s guidance, the sequence is:
- Install the eave drip edge first.
- Apply the membrane directly to the clean roof deck, over the drip edge at the eaves. Other underlayments go over it.
- Follow the manufacturer’s lap instructions for side and end laps.
- At roof features, place the membrane beneath the flashing.
The deck must be dry, and the membrane should not be installed in rain. Wet decks stop the adhesive from bonding. Cold weather also affects adhesion, and manufacturers publish minimum temperatures for application, so ask how your roofer handles a cold-season job.
On the roof, quality shows in the details: no wrinkles, no fish-mouths at the laps, firm rolling, and nails placed above the membrane’s exposed edge rather than through the lap. Ask to see photos of the underlayment stage before the shingles go on. A good crew takes them as a matter of routine.
What ice and water shield costs
Material and installed cost are different numbers, so keep them separate.
Materials. The Roofing Brief reports October 2026 retail prices of about $40 to $112 per roofing square (100 square feet) for mainstream rolls, which works out to roughly $0.40 to $1.12 per square foot. Premium products can run higher. Its examples include GAF WeatherWatch at about $40 to $50 per square, Owens Corning WeatherLock at about $54 to $70, GAF StormGuard at about $60 to $74, and Grace Ice & Water Shield at about $80 to $112.
Installed. Current Cost gives a broad U.S. budgeting range of $0.40 to $1.50 per square foot for materials, $0.60 to $2.50 for labor, and $1.00 to $4.00 installed, assuming a standard residential roof, single-story access, asphalt shingles, and no major demolition. Those are national figures, and a two-story house with steep pitches, many valleys, or tear-off complications will land differently.
Homewyse notes that location, project size, site conditions, minimum labor charges, disposal, contractor markup, sales tax, and permits all change the final price. The takeaway for a homeowner: on a full re-roof, the membrane is a small part of the bill. Eave-only coverage on a typical house adds modest cost for a large reduction in leak risk. Full-deck coverage multiplies the membrane cost many times over, which is another reason to decide on purpose.
We do not publish set prices for roofing, because the roof itself decides the number. We quote after an inspection.
Our perspective: protect the eaves, then fix the attic
We have been in business over 40 years and have completed more than 11,000 projects across Massachusetts and Rhode Island. Here is how we think about ice and water shield.
It is one of the best-value materials on a roof. Used at the eaves, in valleys, and around penetrations, it targets the exact spots where we see leaks start. We would not skip it on a re-roof in this region.
It is also not a cure-all. We see homeowners add membrane and expect the ice dams to disappear. They do not, because the heat is still leaking from the house. The roof then stays dry, but icicles and ridges of ice keep building. The better plan is to treat the roof and the attic as one system: seal the ceiling air leaks, bring insulation up to a sensible level, and keep the attic ventilated. Our team can help with insulation upgrades as part of the same project.
And we are cautious about “cover everything” pitches. Full-deck coverage has a place, but only when the attic can handle it. A roofer who proposes it should be able to explain the ventilation plan too.
— Jess
Repair or replace: when the membrane question comes up
The membrane is only reachable when the shingles come off. That makes it a re-roof decision, not a repair one. If you have an older roof with leaks at the eaves and no ice barrier underneath, spot repairs may only delay the problem. Our guides on repair vs replacement and on missing shingles can help you judge where your roof stands. If a leak has already damaged the ceiling, read whether homeowners insurance covers roof leaks before you start repairs.
Having your roof done with Bruin
If you are planning a new roof in Attleboro, Plainville, Wrentham, Foxboro, Mansfield, or elsewhere in eastern Massachusetts and Rhode Island, we can inspect the roof and the attic, explain which underlayment goes where, and put it in the proposal. We are family-owned and offer in-house financing. See our roof replacement services or the full new roof installation page to get started. For active leaks after a storm, our roof repair team can help.
FAQ
Does ice and water shield actually work?
Yes, for what it is designed to do. It seals around nails and bonds at the laps, so it blocks water forced up under shingles by ice dams or wind-driven rain. It does not prevent ice dams, and it does not fix poor attic insulation or ventilation.
Is it okay to put ice and water shield on the entire roof?
It is allowed in many places, but it is not usually advisable. The membrane can act as a vapor barrier, so a fully covered deck needs good attic ventilation to avoid condensation. Other underlayments cost less, and your local code sets the minimum.
How far up the roof should it go?
The model code calls for the membrane to reach at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, and 36 inches up the slope on roofs of 8:12 or steeper. Local amendments can change this, so confirm with your building department or roofer.
Can it be installed in cold or wet weather?
Not in rain, and the deck must be dry. Cold affects adhesion too, so check the manufacturer’s minimum application temperature and ask your roofer how they handle winter jobs.
Is it worth the extra cost over felt?
At the eaves, valleys, and penetrations, yes. Those are the spots where felt cannot seal around nails or hold back standing water. Across the open field of the roof, felt or synthetic underlayment is usually the more sensible choice.
Sources
- Ice and Water Protector: What is it, Where is it Installed and Why (IKO)
- Roof Eaves Sealed with Self-Adhering Membrane in Cold Climates (Building America)
- Protecting Against Damage from Ice Dams (ARMA technical bulletin)
- Ice Barriers Explained: What Materials Can You Use? (Fine Homebuilding)
- Don’t Underestimate the Importance of Roofing Underlayment (Pro Builder)
- Steep Slope Roofing Underlayment (ARMA)
- Water-managed Roof Assembly (DOE Building Science Education)
- Roof Valleys and Penetrations Sealed (Building America)
- 2021 IRC R905.1.2 Ice barriers (ICC)
- Ice and Water Shield: 2026 Cost + Code Guide (The Roofing Brief)
- Ice and Water Shield Cost Per Square Foot (Current Cost)